NOTE: This is NOT a substitute. I dont think this study shows anything new it was an open trial with small numbers. One further thing. Most TED watchers wouldnt have heard of her before, but Caroline Leaf is a well-known name in western Christendom. And so on so on! Dr Pitt..Ive spent the past few hours going through your material about Dr. Caroline Leaf. Thats not in dispute. Christianity is libertarian, or sometimes deterministic in a theistic way. Spiritual truth and scriptural knowledge will always compliment one another. A critical step for improving mental health is developing non-pharmacological therapies that can treat anxiety and depression effectively without reliance on pharmacological treatments and the accompanying risks for side effects and interactions. Every. My dad had both, plus Machevelianism. Please, spread the word. Prevention of type 2 diabetes mellitus by changes in lifestyle among subjects with impaired glucose tolerance. And such my daughter said to me children are born with cancer children die at birth as you can see so on and so on it reigns upon the Judy and the unjust alike! Something needs to be done, as there is a lot of conflicting and often incorrect information being given by experts and the church leadership needs to learn to be more selective. Thanks again for the question, and all the best to you. I just finished module 1 training with Dr. Caroline Leaf to become a certified Neurocycle facilitator (inaugural class of 2022). Tell the state or national church oversight for your denomination. For our latest peer reviewed article, see here. I recommend planning aheadand setting aside a few hours every morning, evening or afternoon to read something, listen to a new podcast series or audiobook, or learn a new sport or language (or whatever appeals to you!). Leaf teaching that is harmful? Bos, K., et al., Psychiatric outcomes in young children with a history of institutionalization. Analysis of the cohort of children in the Bucharest Early Intervention Project showed that negative affect was the same for both groups. Hilariously ignorant of what shes saying. Recently a friend told me she was coming to a town near us, and highly recommended her. Being a leader doesnt require her to be flawless so we must give her and all leaders grace and room for error. Leaf, as she does speak SO fast, and her husband often does not keep up the sides to keep up with her..which was quite distracting. I think yours is a jolly good underlying question, though Dr Pitt might not take kindly to its being posed to him by way of your setting him a homework assignment that requires him to write 10 to 20 pages. I am more than happy to publish your response, and to publish any response you wish to make public. Toilets and clean running water have nothing to do with stress or thought. I started viewing some of Dr. Leafs online videos. Apr 30, 2023. The experimental subjects were learning how to embrace and make the anxiety and depression work for them and not against them, which is a much more sustainable approach than simply trying to numb or remove emotions and feelings completely. Interesting study, and thanks again for the reference, but it certainly doesnt change my mind when it comes to the validity (or non-validity, as it were) of Dr Leafs teaching. On the 4th of February 2015, Dr Caroline Leaf gave her debut TED presentation, at TEDx Oakes Christian School, California. (Im assuming that to hold the title of Adjunct Professor, hes published peer-reviewed articles. Thanks again for the comment, all the best to you. I would greatly appreciate it if anyone can connect me to Dr Leafs formal writings (peer review). Dialogues Clin Neurosci, 2011. Data collection happens within the app every 21 days for the 20 LMM items and the 8 pro-mindfulness factors as well as a web-based survey (psychdata.com) for user demographics, treatment history, and program experience. http://www.equip.org/article/an-unpersuasive-paradigm/. Creativity, whether we are talking about music, painting, writing, drawing, poetry and so on, can have real, positive effects on the physical health of the brain and on our overall mental health, and has the potential to heal damage from toxic thinking and toxic lifestyles. Each of the six factors represents a set of knowledge, attitudes, or behaviors related to self-regulation and control. Indeed, at any one moment, we need to look at the context of our life: what we are eating, any medications we are taking, our emotional state is, our work schedule, our thought life and so on. 12. Despite this, current pharmacological treatments do not offer lasting treatment or resolution for these disorders (Turner, 2021) and much more neuroscientific research is needed to inform clinical practice and the treatment of mental illness (Ivanov & Schwartz, 2021). Blank. Since the early 1980's, Dr. Caveat emptor always applies. 22. It is only about out two days since somebody advertised to me a fringe church event that involved watching some video or other made by Dr Leaf. So, if our brain is not as healthy as it should be, this can directly affect the gut, and thus our digestive system. Mentally ill ppl believe it, and shes Making money off them. If thoughts have any effect on our health, they are artificially magnified by our clean water and sewerage systems. Her statements should stand up on their own through the rigors of critical analysis. I certainly can not speak for them living in Australia. 5. My question is, even she references a 1979 article and may have errors here and there, what is Dr. This is far from being 2% or 5% as Dr Leafs sources state. Am I to read into what she means by clinical trail, or do you mean that she is not qualified to teach these items? Being right, if you are, is irrelevant if you cannot clearly and concisely make your points. I know a thing or two about narcissism and psychopathy. Dr Leafs PhD and subsequent research shows that her Mind Mapping Technique / Switch On Your Brain program / Geodesic Information Processing Model had no significant net effect on those who were subjected to it. This is why we should never forget that what we think affects how we feel, and our physical health can impact what we think, say and do. So please, show your work!! So sometimes, sickness happens because of genetics or other factors beyond our control. No matter how bad things get or how sick we are, the peace of God which transcends all understanding is the reason we will not be overcome. As I had intended, and as Mr Leaf requested, I published his reply, complete and unabridged (here). Key findings from the 2021 State of the U.S. So it would seem that Dr Leaf isnt teaching us to live under the peace of God, but rather the peace that our minds can purportedly generate under their own strength, something which seemingly doesnt fit well with Pauls teaching on grace (2 Corinthians 12:6-10). This is about everyone who struggles with mental illness. Dr. Leafs teachings have helped me more than the drugs and the so called counselors who didnt help me at all. Int J Biol Sci, 2013. She was one of the first in her field to study how the brain can change (neuroplasticity) with directed mind input. I suggest that you have a read of it. When you go to sleep, you are kind of going into a housekeeping modeeverything is cleaned up, which helps prepare you for the next day. I personally witnessed this for myself. ! You really had to figure it out for yourself It was here I called foul play and warning signs began resounding with great noise and clamour! I understand that you may feel that Dr Leaf has helped you. (LogOut/ Perhaps I can encounter a forum where my questions may be addressed and given their due. So, be intentional about creating thinker breaks throughout your day by taking a few moments every day, or when you are feeling stressed out, to switch off and just mediate on the internal. Happy New Year! She may not be a pure tele-evangelist but she is part of their ecosystem. If our thoughts were that important, then the cognitive component of CBT would have a much stronger effect. Thank you! Big difference. Expertise comes from years in training and practical experience. The fear circuits are already present, only their development is suppressed. If either of you are incorrect in parts of your teaching or practice I cling to Holy Spirit to lead me into all truth. Acute stress can decrease cortisol, and chronic stress doesnt significantly elevate it. Youre welcome to review the body of my work in which I have justified each claim using scientific and scriptural references. Theyre the ones who are vulnerable and theyre the ones I fight for. I find Joyce Meyer far more beneficial and at least she is not claiming to be a theologically trained expert in fact quite the opposite. When it comes to our health, there are no shortcuts! I am amused by your post which continues the long string of unfair criticism fostered by Dr. Pitt. This is why I constantly emphasize getting to the root of our toxic stress and reconceptualizing negative thinking patterns in my research and work, and is why I created my appSwitch, which is based on my scientifically-researched 5-step program, and is designed to help you identify and detox the root of your toxic thoughts and help build healthy, new thinking habits in their place. I apologise if you interpreted my blogs as judgemental, or if you believe there are any misunderstandings. Amazon US = https://goo.gl/7ZLI3H Just get a water filter instead, and avoid industrial chemicals. LEAF'S CERTIFIED FACILITATOR PROGRAM. Writing things down is like putting your brain on paper, and helps to pull up buried memories from the nonconscious mind, adding clarity to what you are thinking about and allowing you to better see the area that needs to be detoxed by helping you to visualize your thoughts. You say, I have a feeling youve read about these illnesses in books, but youve never suffered from them. Its such a shame you didnt read my books before you wrote that comment. Dr Leaf extensively references pseudoscience, and even then, misquotes or incorrectly paraphrases it. Though somehow I doubt she really is involved in a clinical trial, since she has no scientific or academic credibility and has no connection with a university or other research institution. Our results also indicate that there were positive changes in the nonconscious mind (QEEG), conscious mind (LMM), body (telomeres and blood) and the whole person (narrative). Dr. Caroline Leaf will change your healthspan forever by empowering you with simple steps guided by three decades of clinical practice, that will make you more mindful of maintaining your mental and physical health. Dr. Leafs work will teach you to change your mind, and your life, for the better. Its really no different to an article that I read the other day from a group of gut researchers [21] The gut is really your second brain, Greenblatt said. 2. DISCLAIMER Leaf'steamis not allowed publish theirresearch findings ahead of the peer reviewed journal article, here is some information on theircurrent researchprojects. This to me is a red flag, meaning I have a feeling she didnt say what you claim she said. Leaf is also the bestselling author of Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess, Think Learn Succeed, Think and Eat Yourself Smart, and many more. The purpose of this research study and clinical trials: to demonstrate the effectiveness of the 5 Step Neurocycle Program through the use of the latest brain imaging technology, blood tests and wellbeing scales as an affordable, easily accessible and applicable alternative to psychotropic medication to help relieve mental ill-health problems such as anxiety, depression and intrusive thoughts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYG0ZuTv5rs. She was one of the first in her field to study how Leaf then proceeded to deeply examine the science of thought. There are more neurons in the GI tract than anywhere else except the brain. The heart as a mini-brain and the gut as a mini-brain are both figurative expressions. Hi John, thanks for the reply. Did we skip over that year? Eating healthy is also incredibly important when it comes to getting the necessary nutrients to build up the brain. Part of my daily detox routine is my morning cup of mushroom coffee from Four Sigmatic, a company which creates superfood lattes that can help detox the brain and boost cognitive function (you can get a 15% discount off your order atfoursigmatic.com/DRLEAF,or use coupon code DRLEAF at checkout), my daily probiotics from BiOptimizer(my readers can get a free bottle sent to their home by visitingwww.p3om.com/leaffreewith the code leaffreep3om. Construct validity with blood measures also revealed significant relationships between the toxic stress and anxiety subscale and homocysteine levels and DHEA/cortisol ratios. Speaking of claims leaf has said, (like the woman raped), Rather to prove that I was missing the mark when it came to taking care of myself. If you want to continue to follow Dr Leafs teaching, then more power to you. I suspect that my husband humored me, or tolerated my pushing this event. So please give us links and books where you find her quotes, also give us page numbers. Give yourself grace, especially if your life is a little crazy at the moment! A recent paper showed that the corticosterone response required to learn fear is suppressedin the neonate to facilitate attachment, but with enough stress, the corticosterone levels build to the point where amygdala fear learning can commence [24]. Bartram, J. and Cairncross, S., Hygiene, sanitation, and water: forgotten foundations of health. I read it asking What are you I about lady?!! Just because they are sharing something new theyve learned or just because they mention the name of someone who is involved in the charismatic movement, doesnt make them dangerous. Isobel C. Uys. Dr. Caroline Leaf Thats it just ten cases. Why or why not?. I am aware of research thats studied the anxiolytic properties of Atrial Natriuretic Peptide. Sleepis like the street-sweeper of the body, and is essential when it comes to our brain health. Change). For the benefit of Dr Leafs followers, and for the scientific and Christian community at large, I would appreciate your response. 298(14): 1685-7) Negative or toxic thoughts are often the result of an underlying disease process not the cause of it. These include the following. viii, 243 p. 20. I would take you more seriously if you would just give me the info where you found her quote and maybe even included the youtube video of where you found this quote below? In her latest blog post, Dr Caroline Leaf attempted to tackle the complex topic of Alzheimer disease. Dr Leaf did her PhD in 1998. Reminders are only sent to those who have not yet completed the survey. I have devoted a whole chapter to breaking down Dr Leafs 98% factoid, showing exactly why its wrong and clearly outlining what real science says, complete with the page number from Dr Leafs book, and the complete list of references. Hutter, C.M., et al., Characterization of gene-environment interactions for colorectal cancer susceptibility loci. By Dr. Caroline Leaf on September 22, 2021 In this podcast (episode #319) and blog, I talk to Kati Morton, a licensed therapist, author, and mental health advocate, about how to identify and cope with PTSD, dealing with social media trauma, reframing toxic self-talk, why things often feel like they get worse before they get better, and more! Its no different to Dr Leaf and her teaching, which is scientifically baseless and not only will I not support people using it, but I will also actively discourage people from using it. I think its fair to say that while Dr Leaf draws her conclusions from some scientific documents, there is more than enough research that contradicts her statements and opinions. Again, I will discuss this further soon. Focusing on the mind is critical to our health, as I mention in all my books, talks, products and researchwe need to exercise the brain like we exercise our bodies. She is just sharing her research and her personal experience to bring some hope and a natural alternative to anxiety infested, pharmaceutically dependent, malnutritioned, stressed out people. In terms of cancer, I dont have time to exhaustively list every cancer but of the top four listed in the review Cancer Statistics 2013 [6] , here are the articles that list the gene x environment interactions: So the most common cancer is not linked to any environmental factors at all, and the others have genetic influences of 25% to more than 50%. PLoS Med, 2010. 3. I attended the University of Queensland where Professor Ian Frazer was based. Keep up the good work buddy. I was searching for peer reviews to support a formal research proposal. Were all one in Christ. And, if you find that you fall asleep and suddenly wake up with a rush of adrenalin, turn on the light read a bit of a book, do some work, or journal about your thoughts (I often do this when I cant sleep), which can help you organize what you are thinking and bring some clarity to the situation. Just because I did a bachelors degree in arts and did two papers in sociology doesnt make me a sociologist! I have not taken any revenue from any work relating to Dr Leaf. https://adc.bmj.com/content/early/2017/09/20/archdischild-2017-313375. CLICK HERE TO REGISTER FOR DR. You may or may not have read my final two paragraphs from the third post, in which I acknowledged that I may have misunderstood where she was coming from, but that I would welcome her response. That the result is reversed confirms that neonates and infants require adequate stimulation of both fear and love pathways to grow into an emotionally robust child, because the brain is pre-wired for both but requires further stimulation for adequate development. Her book leaves you not only hanging But is so ridiculously ridiculously ridiculously written with little understanding of the practical outcome of this theory in practice that it pains me. After the course ends, you can rewatch the training sessions, use the app Neurocycle and access the book Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess to complete the open book exam needed for certification, which has to be done within 9-10 weeks after training. Youre more than welcome to disagree with the conclusions I draw but I disagree that it is unsound. Science is deterministic, in a material way. I also noticed you said above: She may not be a pure tele-evangelist but she is part of their ecosystem. Did its feebled thoughts and behaviors result in its disease? Indeed, there are several counter-arguments against your assertion that thoughts are in any way connected with low mood or depression. During her years in clinical practice and her work with thousands of underprivileged teachers and students in her home country of South Africa and in the USA, she developed her theory (called the Geodesic Information Processing theory) of how we think, build memory, and learn, into tools and processes that have transformed the lives of hundreds of thousands of individuals with Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE), learning disabilities (ADD, ADHD), autism, dementias and mental ill-health issues like anxiety and depression. This applies to myself and Dr Leaf. Just because they are sharing something new theyve learned or just because they mention the name of someone who is involved in the charismatic movement, doesnt make them dangerous. Your feeling that Dr Leafs ministry of fake science is working for you doesnt mean her teaching is accurate. Leaf'steamis not allowed publish theirresearch findings ahead of the peer reviewed journal article, here is some information on theircurrent research projects. Are you unfamiliar with the phrase flame war? I have a wry smile now, both at your play on words and the fact I missed it. 120(12): 1141-63. And there it is!! During her years in clinical practice and her work with thousands of underprivileged teachers and students in South Africa and the USA as a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist, she developed an original theory of the science of thought, called Neurocycle, as well mind-management tools and processes based on herresearch and practice. Be wary of natural or alternative healers that want to sell you chelation or some herbal remedy. But to take a mans theory widely cited in his field of education and psychology and make it seem to lay people its your theory then you better watch out! Study 1s findings suggested that these 20 questions forming the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) survey tool have both structural validity and consistent reliability across both samples. In treatment vs. control comparisons, participants significantly improved on performance of all five brain waves, supporting a likely decrease in anxiety and stress, as well as an increase in relaxation, learning, and autonomy. And I don't have to wait long to start helping people professionally. The data collection protocol begins with an email invitation, and non-responders are contacted up to three times by email reminders spaced by 5-7 days each. The technology has advanced significantly, and genetic discoveries are lightyears ahead of where they were more than three decades ago. It was a frightful situation. As we continue to thank God for His glorious freedom we also celebrate free thinking. 15. In a general sense, I have found some helpful information in Leafs approaches to well being. If he chose to respond, Im sure his voice would have much more authority than Dr Leafs. It is heavily researched and thoroughly referenced. She repeated the same statement in her most recent book so it is something she is confident in. Rate and comment on Dr Leafs books on Goodreads and Amazon, Google, B&N etc. Youll also have to forgive my confusion, but Dr Leaf also wrote, Dr H.F. Nijhout (Metaphors and the Role of Genes and Development, 1990) genes control biology and not the other way around. So is she saying that genes DO control development? If you are battling to sleep, take the time to look at where you are in life: how busy you are, what you are eating, and so on, seeing if you can improve your sleeping habits by taking more time to rest, for example, or improving your diet. As such, the numbers are too small to have any real meaning. I took so Caroline leaf at a church sponsored womens event in California many years ago! Kunes, J. and Zicha, J., The interaction of genetic and environmental factors in the etiology of hypertension. Thanks Elroy. for user demographics, treatment history, and program experience. Fight By Teachers were provided with webinars covering the rationale behind and 5-step process of the NeurocycleTM, a tool for mental health detoxing and management. In fact, the more you build your brain, the more confident, and less anxious, you will be when faced with a challenge! A final set of 71 items was selected for the initial questionnaire, and exploratory factor analysis (EFA) and confirmatory factor analyses (CFA) found 20 items nested within six factors that explained 71.9% of the overall variance. Leaf and her team are amazing and continue to be very responsive to our questions to ensure we are fully equipped and confident as CFS. Personally, I dont think the generalisation applies). I cant say Im particularly surprised though. For our latest peer reviewed article, see. 27. QEEG measurements of 11 NeurocycleTM participants were performed before using the NeurocycleTM, after the first 21 days, and after the final 63 days to assess mental health improvements. I had a two for one deal and also had the other book, The Perfect You., I was excited to read this as when I flicked through I saw Howard Gardners theory made up most of it and Im an avid advocate and admirer not to mention classroom educator and promoter of the NINE theories of Multiple Intelligience. Indeed, one of Dr Leafs own references concluded that Although stressors are often associated with illness, the majority of individuals confronted with traumatic events and chronic serious problems remain disease-free. (Cohen, S., et al., Psychological stress and disease. No dietary or environmental cause has yet been identified [7]. Dear Dr. Pitt, Sleep helps the mind, brain and body regenerate. Love to hear more if youre willing to share. If you want to rely on it, thats up to you. It does not determine our health. In the blog to which you referred, Dr Leaf makes a number of statements that are intended to support her case. 13(4): 463-74. And thank you for investing your time in listening and responding to my offerings! God or man? She spoke as a speaker on Saturday and she spoke in a fast paced manner! Throughout our research trial, we saw significantly positive changes in the experimental group on a cellular level (based on changes in telomeres, the caps on chromosomes), in electrical activity in the brain (based on QEEG-measured changes in the brain), in psychosocial profiling (based on changes in psychological scales and narratives), and in blood tests (including changes cortisol and homocysteine levels). He sees, He Knows, HE hears! At one point when the host of the event was doing a short interview with Dr. How can I get my money back and complain about this foul thought?! OK I am super glad to have stumbled across this information! She tested my bloodwork, as well as my micronutrient levels and also did a saliva test to check my cortisol. Koorong = https://goo.gl/2kBlY2 Instead, it was three hours of Dr. Over the past few decades, many studies have contributed to utilizing electroencephalography (EEG) measurements to assess mental health through correlations between historically pre-defined frequency bands in the power spectrum alpha, beta, delta, theta, and gamma and specific mental health conditions (Newson & Thiagarajan, 2019). It seems they want to protect their house-of-cards ministry any way they can. So, when it comes to our mental and physical health, it is imperative that we take a complete lifestyle approach, especially in todays world, where, for the first time in years, people are dying younger and younger from preventable, lifestyle diseases. The purpose of this step is straightforward: to gather awareness of and embrace what you are hearing, reading, and experiencing, and to get information into the brain.
Aries Horoscope Tomorrow,
Articles C